411
Government Faces Murder Allegations Over Stilfontein Miner Deaths
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6b1fa/6b1fa993962be7fffb0322f91f0018884c2b1953" alt=""
The Stilfontein Crisis Committee is exploring legal action against the South African government following the deaths of over 70 miners who were trapped underground for more than two months.
This week, more than 70 deceased miners were brought to the surface from disused shafts in Stilfontein, North West. These individuals were part of a larger group of illegal miners caught in a standoff with authorities over unsafe mining practices.
Christopher Rutledge, Chairperson of the Stilfontein Crisis Committee, made strong allegations during an interview with Newzroom Afrika. He accused government officials of indifference and of making remarks suggesting their intent to leave the miners to die.
“We are going to consider a number of routes, including charging individuals and the state with murder,” Rutledge said. He added that the committee would push for an inquiry akin to the Life Esidimeni investigation, which followed the deaths of 141 mentally-ill patients.
Rutledge detailed the perilous environment miners faced while trapped in Shaft 11. He claimed the government was fully informed about the risks.
“The miners in Shaft 11 had no safe exit route. The only alternative was Shaft 10, where dangerous structural conditions made escape nearly impossible,” he said.
The compromised Shaft 10 was described as having “rusty, rickety iron poles” that miners would need to climb for nearly two kilometers. Many who attempted this escape route reportedly fell to their deaths.
The Crisis Committee believes the government’s inaction constitutes a violation of constitutional rights. Rutledge indicated plans to seek constitutional damages as part of the committee’s legal strategy.
“This tragedy highlights systemic failures and negligence,” Rutledge argued. “Lives could have been saved with timely intervention.”
In a parallel effort, 246 miners have been rescued from the same mine. The operation, led by specialist healthcare teams and police, provided medical attention to nine miners.
Colonel Athlenda Mathe, National Police Spokesperson, reported that the remaining miners were taken into custody. They include individuals from Mozambique, Lesotho, Zimbabwe, and five South African nationals.
The rescued miners, along with alleged masterminds behind the illegal mining operation, are expected to appear in court on Friday.
As investigations continue, the Stilfontein Crisis Committee has vowed to hold the government accountable.
“This is not just about illegal mining,” Rutledge concluded. “It’s about the value of human life and the responsibility of the state to protect it.”
Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter , TikTok and Instagram
For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com