BEE Premiums: A Costly Policy Failing Ordinary South Africans

Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) was introduced in South Africa to address the economic inequalities entrenched by apartheid. A key component of this policy is the BEE premium—an additional amount the government pays when awarding tenders to businesses with higher BEE credentials, even if their bid is not the most cost-effective. While the intention behind BEE premiums is noble, their implementation has largely failed to deliver meaningful economic transformation, instead burdening ordinary South Africans with high costs and limited benefits.

How BEE Premiums Work

Under current rules, businesses with higher BEE scores are given preferential treatment in government tenders. If two companies submit similar bids, the one with the higher BEE score wins the contract, even if its price is higher. Contracts under R50 million can carry a 25% premium, while those over R50 million are capped at 11.1%. This system was designed to empower black-owned businesses and promote economic inclusion. However, in practice, it has fallen short of its goals.

A Policy Failing Its Purpose

Despite billions spent through BEE procurement, the policy has done little to address South Africa’s high unemployment rate, particularly among black South Africans, who were meant to benefit the most. Since the late 1990s, black unemployment has nearly doubled, while only a small, politically connected elite has reaped the rewards of BEE premiums. The majority of South Africans have seen no tangible improvement in their economic circumstances.

Economic Concerns Raised by Global Institutions

The International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the World Bank have both raised concerns about the economic impact of BEE premiums. The IMF reports that South Africa’s fiscal multiplier—a measure of how government spending contributes to economic growth—has turned negative in recent years. This means that the money spent on BEE premiums has not stimulated economic growth or improved service delivery. Similarly, the World Bank describes BEE premiums as costly and inefficient, arguing that they benefit a small elite rather than fostering widespread economic development.

Lack of Transparency and Accountability

The Zondo Commission, which investigated state capture in South Africa, highlighted the lack of transparency in procurement processes. This opacity undermines the effectiveness of BEE premiums and prevents the public from understanding the true cost of these payments. The Commission recommended prioritizing value-for-money over BEE preferences, which often distort procurement processes and lead to wasteful spending.

A particularly troubling aspect of the BEE premium system is the National Treasury’s refusal to disclose the full extent of these payments. Despite estimates suggesting that BEE premiums cost taxpayers R150 billion annually, the Treasury has not made this information publicly available. This lack of transparency violates constitutional principles of accountability and leaves taxpayers in the dark about how their money is being spent.

A Call for Reform

While redress is necessary to address the legacy of apartheid, the current implementation of BEE has not achieved its intended goals. The Democratic Alliance (DA) believes that a race-based system is inherently flawed and that empowerment should be based on need, not race. The DA proposes scrapping the BEE premium system altogether, ensuring that value-for-money is prioritized in procurement processes. This change would eliminate the need for tax increases or additional loans, freeing up resources to stimulate economic growth and create jobs.

BEE premiums, though well-intentioned, have become a costly and inefficient policy that fails to deliver meaningful economic transformation. Instead of empowering the majority of South Africans, they have enriched a small elite while burdening taxpayers with unnecessary costs. Greater transparency, accountability, and a focus on value-for-money are essential to ensure that South Africa’s economic policies benefit all its citizens, not just a privileged few. By reforming the BEE system, South Africa can move closer to achieving true economic inclusion and sustainable growth.

Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter , TikTok and Instagram

For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com